TOMS: taking another look


I was initially put off by TOMS’ business model because it seemed that they were really just in it for personal gain; when you pay $40.00+ for shoes that won’t last more than a couple seasons, you better hope that people are getting more than one pair of substandard shoes. But I have to give them credit for creating a more ethical, charity-minded business model that has since been copied by dozens of companies.

And they’ve really improved since the last time I perused the site. They still give shoes, but they’ve also created jobs that provide a living wage, donate to various charitable organizations, and feature like-minded companies in their marketplace. These improvements make me feel better about backing them.


toms by fracturedradiance featuring TOMS

When TOMS first came on the scene, I was worried that their model was just another advertising angle. But recent changes make it clear that they really do intend to positively and sustainably impact the world – by spreading awareness, creating jobs, providing resources, and building up others. Good for them!

Do you like TOMS? I owned a pair a couple years ago; they were comfortable, but the quality was so-so.

*Click styleboard to be redirected to image sources.

follow photo

butbl butets butfb butp


  1. More than anything, I'm impressed that they're trying to be more transparent, even if they're not quite there yet. But I agree that a truly fair trade company would be better to support. I tend to buy most of my shoes secondhand on ebay.

  2. Yeah; I'm still not completely sold on the one-for-one model as it's employed by a number of companies. But where there are no other alternatives, it's better than buying from a company that has no ethical goals.

  3. I was always off-put by TOMS because it seems like they were being intentionally vague about where and how their shoes were manufactured. When they first came out they had a statement on their website about the manufacturing being ethical, and then they removed it and didn't address the point at all for a long time. The last time I looked (several months ago), they had added a report on their manufacturing that focused on human trafficking-related concerns. It was a step forward, but it also kind of missed the point by focusing only on that specific issue. I don't know if they have any better disclosure now.

  4. I am curious about Toms. I was put off by the brand at first, too, and I've heard that the shoes they donate are not the same quality as the type they sell. But I did get a catalog last month and was impressed by what they're doing. It's so hard to find ethical or even made in the USA shoes, so I think this might be a great place to start. I have read about SoleRebels, which are fair trade and made in Ethiopia, but I haven't purchased a pair yet.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: